6 minute read

How Asset vs Stock Sales Impact You as the Seller

You're in the phase of selling your company.

You've likely skimmed a few articles explaining the difference between an asset sale and a stock sale. They tend to recap things like:

• Stock Sale: The buyer acquires your entire legal entity: LLC, corporation, everything in it.
• Asset Sale: The buyer sets up their own company and purchases your business's key assets, while your entity stays in your name.

That's the tip of the iceberg. The structure you choose (or agree to) doesn't just affect taxes, it shapes everything from your post-sale liabilities to how cash in the bank is handled.

Let's dig into what this means for you.

Why Buyers Tend to Push for Asset Sales

In deals under $10M (most small to midsize businesses), buyers almost always prefer an asset sale. Here's why they lean that way:

1. They're Protecting Themselves from Liability
In an asset deal, the buyer isn't stepping into your legal shoes. They don't want to inherit past problems, whether it's an unresolved lawsuit, unpaid vendor, or a tax audit that hasn't closed yet. They want a fresh start, and that means leaving your legal entity (and any baggage) with you.

2. They Want a Clean Financial Slate
An asset sale means the buyer starts fresh with their own books and bank accounts. Your debts, loans, and financial obligations typically stay on your side of the table.

3. They Want Tax Flexibility
Buyers tend to get tax perks in asset deals. They can allocate the purchase price across different asset classes and depreciate them, lowering their taxable income. This is a big reason they push for this structure, especially with SBA lenders involved.

The reality: In most asset sales, cash and cash equivalents stay with you. If your business has $200,000 sitting in the bank, you keep that. The buyer isn't purchasing your legal entity or your bank accounts, they're buying the operating assets: customers, contracts, IP, equipment, inventory, goodwill, etc.

Note that some fractional AR or working capital may still be negotiated, but for the most part, funds on the balance sheet are yours.

What You Keep (and What They Buy)

This is the part most sellers don't realize until due diligence: in an asset sale, the cash and liabilities in your business usually stay with you.

If there's $150K in your business checking account, that doesn't automatically go to the buyer in an asset sale. The same goes for credit card debt or loans. What they're buying are the operational components (your revenue generation), not your bank balance.

That said, things like accounts receivable or inventory may be part of the discussion, depending on how working capital is structured in the deal.

What the Sale Actually Looks Like (On Your End)

Once the deal closes:

• You still own your LLC or corporation.
  It's yours until you shut it down. That includes the bank accounts, tax ID, and payroll accounts.
• You settle the remaining obligations.
  This means clearing out the bank accounts, closing tax filings, and dissolving the entity if you choose.
• You transfer the operating assets.
  You hand off the assets: customer list, website, domain, CRM, trademarks, IP, contracts (if assignable), and team members move over to the buyer's newly formed entity. That's what they're buying: the engine, not the frame.

You keep the shell, they drive off with the business.

The Misconception That Trips Up Sellers

It's easy for first-time sellers to assume "asset sale" means someone is picking your business apart, choosing what segments they want to buy and coming up with what those are worth.

Not true.

Most profitable companies, especially in service, SaaS, and ecommerce, sell through asset deals. Not because they're broken, but because liability, tax considerations, and financing make it easier for the buyer in an asset structure.

You're not selling scraps. You're selling the whole operation, just not the legal wrapper around it.

When a Stock Sale Might Actually Benefit You

Even though asset sales are more common, here's when you might want to push for a stock deal:

1. Cleaner Hand-Off
If your business has dozens of contracts, vendor logins, or licenses that would be a hassle to transfer individually, a stock sale might simplify things. The legal entity stays intact, and those assets don't need to be reassigned.

2. Tax Strategy
Depending on your CPA's advice, a stock sale could result in better tax treatment, like a larger portion being taxed as long-term capital gains rather than ordinary income.

3. Regulated Industries
In businesses with permits, licenses, or accreditations (like healthcare, logistics, or government contracts), keeping the original legal entity intact may be the only feasible option.

4. Contracts with Transferability Clauses
Some contracts automatically terminate if you transfer them. But if you sell the entity instead? They might stay valid. This is critical for businesses built around recurring or enterprise revenue. If your company's revenue structure is heavily contract-based, make sure the contracts are assignable. If not, a buyer might be wary of acquiring the business (unless they are willing to take the high risk of re-signing each client) or a stock sale could be more attractive.

What Sellers Should Know Going In

The structure is part of the negotiation. And in most main street and lower middle market deals, asset sales remain the default starting point, especially if lenders like SBA financing are involved.

It impacts:

• Your post-sale tax bill
• Your exposure to future claims or lawsuits
• Which contracts or assets can be transferred smoothly
• Whether you keep or close your company after the sale

While it's tempting to let your attorney or CPA drive the conversation, remember: structure is a negotiation point. Just make sure your advisors explain the implications in plain English and tailor their guidance to your deal specifically, no need for overkill.

Bottom Line for Sellers

Don't get fooled by the cookie-cutter definitions floating around. Deal structure can be where real money is won or lost.

Before you sign anything, make sure you understand:

• The tax bill you'll actually walk away with
• Any liabilities you could still be responsible for
• What happens to your contracts, licenses, and customer relationships
• The status of your legal entity after the sale

Work with a lawyer who understands deal flow and keeps things practical for the size of your transaction.

---